Lebanese reporter under fire for non-impartial reporting, privileged on-camera behavior 

Lebanese reporter Nawal Berri is currently trending online, but for all the wrong reasons. Having failed to deliver an accurate update on the protest that was taking place Monday night to commemorate the rise of the 2015 anti-government civil movements in Beirut’s Riad Solh Square, she resorted to an abrupt end to her live coverage, after activists began to chant slogans against the Speaker of Lebanon’s Parliament Nabih Berri, labeling them as “zo3ran” (meaning: thugs) before walking off camera.

Berri, who is known for having close ties to the House Speaker, has in the past protested the inclusion of the latter’s name in anti-corruption movements, referring to the long-time politician  as “kbeer al-3ayle” (meaning: the family’s eldest or patriarch). The head of the Amal Movement has been Lebanon’s unrivaled Speaker since 1992, and is seen as being among the country’s most corrupt politicians by civil society activists.

Upon the end of the live transmission, activist Firas Bou Hatoum approached the reporter to offer an explanation, stating that those who chanted slogans do not represent the bulk of the movement. She reportedly responded by saying: “I will bury all those who speak ill of ‘kbeer al-3ayle’ [Speaker Berri] … He is the crown on their heads …”

Partiality in reporting:

Nawal Berri is no stranger to controversy. Last year and during the peak of the August 22 anti-government protests, Berri also made headlines when she and fellow journalist Firas Hatoum exchanged insults on social media after the latter had criticized her coverage. According to Hatoum, Berri was unprofessional and was more concerned with reporting on her appearance, namely hair and makeup, after water cannons were directed at protesters and reporters alike. This resulted in a heated debate between the two -one that media critics say should not have occurred.

Nawal Berri covering the anti-government protests in August 2015 | Source: AnNahar\FadiShami

In April this year she displayed clear partiality to Ali Elamine in the controversial child recovery/abduction case involving Australian mother Sally Faulkner and the 60 Minutes crew. Berri, who’s the cousin of Elamine, accused Faulker of having revoked custody of her children and of being an unfit mother. The information presented in this report was unverified and biased. Elamine like Berri also enjoys close ties to the House Speaker and is said to have used those very same connections in the high profile case.

In 2013 she was at the receiving end of heavy criticism when she produced a report on the country’s dwindling resources and donor funds lost to Syrian and non-Syrian refugees “who also take up space”. Berri concluded at the end of what she called an investigative report, that street dwellers include nawar (an Arabic term for several sedentary communities used primarily in Syria, Lebanon, and Palestine. The term is regarded derogatory, used for several diverse ethnic groups especially in the context of panhandling) while asking some for the identification from within a moving vehicle.

Skewed media landscape:

Berri clearly displays privilege in her latest on-air emotional outburst, as reporters are not usually granted control to cut-off live transmissions if conditions around them are unfavorable. Such shots are made by producers and news chiefs alone. A reporter can only make such calls in the case that his/her life and the lives of the crew members involved are in direct danger.

Having said that it is important to point out that Berri is not alone in this behavior. The media’s quest for funding and ratings has resulted in a myriad controversies involving the coverage of reporters, media personalities and journalists. The culture of nepotism and favoritism has affected the media landscape whereby a majority of journalists act as political defenders rather than observers without any sense of accountability. In a sense they act out of fear rather than duty as they want to maintain their privileges and safeguard their jobs.

But the question is: is it not time for our media to realize its faults? Recent studies  point to growing resentment by younger viewers towards traditional media outlets, for reasons that include biased reporting and favoritism. Our country’s media landscape is clearly a mess, and will continue to be so long as media outlets continue to give people “what they want” rather than “what they need”.

Personally, I do not believe that anyone is immune given the rising pressures of the industry and lack of opportunities, and I certainly do not condone the personal online campaign against Berri or anyone else for that matter, but I do hope that all readers would instead engage in a debate on what our media landscape needs. We must attempt to break the walls of the echo chambers that are arising between groups, viewers, and media outlets through dialogue.  It’s high time that our media listens.

About 
Nadine Mazloum is an Australian born, Beirut bred multimedia journalist, editor, and blogger. She most recently worked as StepFeed's Senior Editor. Before that, she was the news editor and resident blogger for the Lebanese Broadcasting Corporation International [LBCI] and has held several positions with well-known media outlets both locally and internationally. Her work appears online both on LBCI and on her personal blog, NewsroomNomad©.

2 Comments

  1. Menaribo

    August 23, 2016 - 2:17 pm
    Reply

    Well, she likes Berri, as much as any other journalist or reporter in Lebanon who has at least a political or religious affiliation.

  2. Wadih El Hayek

    August 23, 2016 - 10:34 pm
    Reply

    One incident is still to be mentioned. Berri went into FSA controlled areas in Syria using her American passport and when her piece aired she blatantly mentioned that the FSA were fooled by an American passport and talking in English. Her commentary resulted in making the jobs of all other journalists going into Syria extremely harder and considerably much more dangerous.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *